Jeffrey and Katelyn still have the original text from high school that set them up on their very first date. After a few years of long-distance marked by visits while they attended different schools, they both studied abroad in Australia and had the chance to travel and explore together. After college, they reunited in New York City, and in their words, “never looked back.” Jeffrey proposed on a walk along the water near their apartment on a rare, mild December day. Choosing Nantucket as their wedding destination felt like an easy decision for Jeffrey and Katelyn, who envisioned a weekend with timeless island ease. “What mattered most to us was sharing the place with our friends and family in a way that felt authentic,” they explained. With the help of Handy & Dallaire Events, they leaned into the island’s natural offerings — food, flowers, and venue — hosting at the Sankaty Beach Club for a celebration captured by Rebecca Love Photography that was quintessentially “Nantucket.”
Unique detail: cohesive pattern
A tablecloth pattern discovered by Katelyn’s mother became a subtle thread of cohesion, appearing across the invitations by Wouldn’t It Be Lovely, escort cards, and even as a bar wrap.
Nantucket wedding weekend itinerary
The weekend struck a balance of welcoming yet understated, with events that included a bridal luncheon, a golf outing for Jeffrey and his friends, and a group trip to a local brewery. “The best part of the wedding weekend was the energy,” the couple reflected, noting how their guests arrived ready to dance, celebrate, and embrace the joy of the moment.
Featured designer: Oscar de la Renta
Katelyn wore an Oscar de la Renta gown in silk faille with floral applique — a classic design with a summer twist.
You may also like
A charming Nantucket garden party wedding with handmade details
Nantucket wedding filled with coastal elegance
The magic of Nantucket enchants in this coastal wedding
Quintessentially Nantucket bridesmaids
The bridal party wore Lula Kate in the perfect shade of coastal Nantucket blue, complemented by small white and green bouquets tied with blue ribbon.
Ceremony on the bluff
Their ceremony along the bluff featured readings, prayers, and concluded with the breaking of the glass, set against the sweeping backdrop of the water.
Must-do: Lighthouse wedding portraits
Nautical touches and a blue-and-white palette captured the essence of the island, while the newlyweds stole away for portraits by the lighthouse.
Reception idea: family seating
At dinner, the couple chose to sit with their immediate families, carving out meaningful, quiet moments amid the day’s excitement.
Blue and white table numbers
Pale blue and white table numbers were delicately balanced amidst summery centerpieces courtesy of Flowers On Chestnut.
Pearl-accented place cards
Guests found their table number thanks to place cards with 3-dimensional pearl accents.
Perfectly personalized details
Guests enjoyed personal elements such as custom matchbooks, monogrammed cocktail napkins, and frames filled with the first set of texts that connected them as a couple!
Blue and white wedding cake
The newlyweds cut into a three-tier wedding cake by Pâtisserie by PPX Events with an asymmetrical floral design made of white roses, anemones, and blue wildflowers.
