Engagement Rings

Find engagement rings you actually love
Browse Rings →

Find Your Venue

Explore venues for every wedding style
Browse Venues →

Wedding Favors

Custom chocolate bars for every event
Shop Now →

Win a Luxe Escape

St. Maarten trip + $1.3K in gifts!
Enter Now →

Ad Placeholder Title

Ad Placeholder Subtitle Featured here

The Bachelor Contestant’s Most Extravagant Maui Proposal

Share

Man proposes to woman on decorated wooden staircase

Bri Amaranthus’ Engagement Story

Read on to hear all about Bachelor Contestant Bri Amaranthus’ over the top extravagant Maui proposal.

On the morning of January 14, 2020, I woke up unaware that my life would change, forever. I sipped my coffee on the deck, alone, overlooking the dreamy ocean waves that crashed as I listened to my favorite morning bird sing its song. A just-awake Cory slid open the glass door to join me, rubbing my shoulders with a soft kiss on my cheek. Looking back now, I can’t imagine how his mind must have been reeling – he was hours away from putting in motion the most extraordinary proposal I’ve ever heard of.

Man leaving luxury villa with briefcase and documents

I found my first clue during a normal (read: intense) pickleball game. During a time out, I called a vintage car shop to see what the cost and availability to rent a 1957 Porsche 356 Speedster convertible to cruise top down under the sweet sun would be. On the other end of the phone call, the owner replied, “Sorry, we do not rent to pirates.” and hung up on me…

Pirate flag and Clue 1 lying on a carpet floorPirate at the beach with skull and crossbones flag

I stared at my phone incredulously. How did she know that we nickname ourselves “pirates” when we are on vacation? Had our reputation (read: piña coladas intake) made it across the island? Did she follow me on Instagram? Was I on Punk’d?

Jaw-dropped, I said to Cory, “I’m not sure if I’m losing my mind but she just told me they don’t rent to pirates.”

He said it would make sense later and gave instructions that I needed to find the hidden Pirate flag in the condo. 

Four smiling women on a sailboat enjoy a sunny day

I wasn’t on this hunt alone. My best friends D and Kristin were fellow pirates with the same clue. We hustled to the condo, where we found the flag and the game began!

There aren’t enough characters for me to write out every clue but I will say this…

The 48-hour scavenger hunt led me across the island of Maui, along the curves of the golden beaches and back. My emotions reeled as I tried to figure out every clue, with the hope in my heart that it might be a proposal. 

However, my brain was adamant that it couldn’t be a proposal because my most trusted people would NEVER lie to me. Turns out… My Mom, Dad and best friends are GREAT liars and were in cahoots with Cory (and his printed, detailed itinerary) every step of the way. And, boy oh boy, did Cory surprise me. His thoughtful planning, utmost respect and ingenious creativity shined through in the most endearing way on what became the best day of my life (so far).

Woman shops at Gucci store with luxury handbagCouple on a wooden treehouse deck in tropical foliage

What will I remember most about it? Not the Gucci shopping spree, mai tai happy hour, private tree house award-winning dining experience, Hotel Wailea getaway, morning at the spa, Porsche speedster, or whale watching cruise…

Woman poses with a classic silver Porsche convertible

I’ll remember the happiness that bubbled out of me when I saw Cory waiting for me under a dramatic canopy of mango and avocado trees with the ocean stunning behind him and the sunset peeking through at the end of the path lined with every card we have written each other. 

Man proposes to woman in lush green garden setting

Couple holding hands walking outdoors happy and in love

I sprinted to him (and almost ruined the photographer’s shot in the process). I couldn’t help it. He got down on one knee with a magnificent princess cut ring in his steady hand and the world stood still in the most flawless moment. Spoiler alert: I said yes.

Elegant floral centerpiece with an X marks the spot card

Love card with forever question near white flowersBeach proposal ring square cut diamond engagement

I’ve never dreamed of a fantasy engagement or my perfect wedding. However, I have always prayed and wished for a man and partner in life. I dreamed of a marriage built from support, honesty, adventure and LOVE. Somehow, I ended up with it all. Lucky me.

instagram post

Accommodations: Hotel Wailea
Chef: Cupanion's Kitchen + Coffee
Dallas Cowboys and Mavericks reporter: Bri Amaranthus
Fiance: Cory
Jewelry: Kassab Jewelers
Maui Luxury Boating: Teralani Sailing Adventures
Photographers: Reagan Kastner Photography
Rentals: Maui Roadsters

Continue to

Next Story

From a custom Alena Leena gown to a moonlit dance party overlooking the cliffs, every wedding detail felt deeply personal and effortlessly elegant.
Set against the lush gardens and open fields of Hidden Meadows, this late-summer wedding beautifully blended personal tradition with modern celebration.
A romantic barn wedding featuring soft creamy florals, fresh fruit tablescapes, a lush outdoor ceremony, and an elegant barn reception.